November 19, 2026
A three-bedroom house at 1833 Creekside Avenue in north Sweetwater has 1,150 square feet and an asking price of $203,990. A few lots away, 1657 Creekside Avenue has 200 more square feet and lists at $236,990. On Fortezza Homes' current Creekside page, the four-bedroom Dinah plan is the largest at 1,850 square feet and $325,990. Builder prices change, so confirm them before planning around them.
Divide each price by its square footage and the lineup works out to between $175 and $177 a square foot from the smallest plan to the largest. The Maci at 1917 Creekside Avenue is 1,250 square feet for $218,990. The Tiffany at 1600 Magnolia Lane is 1,450 square feet for $256,990. Both land in the same range. The price tracks the size of the new house, and it sits far above what the rest of Sweetwater's housing is valued at. That gap between new-home prices and existing-home values explains most of what has happened in Sweetwater housing over the past decade, and it shapes how a buyer should judge a Creekside home today.
Older homes make up nearly all of Sweetwater's housing, and on paper they are valued far below new construction. The Nolan Central Appraisal District's 2025 annual report counts 5,316 single-family homes in Nolan County with a combined market value of $540,676,759. That averages about $101,700 per home. The West Central Texas Council of Governments' 2025 regional housing study put the 2022 median owner-occupied home value at $91,300 for Nolan County and $91,200 for the Sweetwater census division.
Both are measures of the whole housing stock, and neither is a recent sale price. Still, they show the problem a homebuilder faced here. The smallest new house in Creekside costs about twice the county's average appraised home. When a new house has to sell for double what its neighbors are valued at, builders tend to pass on the town.
For years, Sweetwater's builders did just that. Miesha Adames, executive director of Sweetwater Economic Development, told KTAB at the 2022 Creekside groundbreaking that the city "had 10 new homes built within a 10-year period, so on average, a home a year." In the same report she said the last large development was probably built in the 1980s, and the bigger homes near the country club went up in the 1950s and 60s. Two years later, she told KTAB the reason for the city's response: "We saw that the market wasn't driving itself and bringing single-family housing to Sweetwater and home builder interest, so that's why we felt the need to offer incentives."
Creekside exists because three parties each covered part of the gap between new-home prices and local values.
The first was the city's economic development corporation. A 2017 housing study commissioned by the Sweetwater Municipal Development District found that the housing shortage was hurting business recruitment and retention. Sweetwater ISD, Ludlum Measurements and Rolling Plains Memorial Hospital all said it made hiring and keeping employees harder. In August 2021, SEED partnered with Rick and Holly Betenbough of Lubbock on a 29.5-acre subdivision near Hoyt Street. It committed up to $1,330,000 for infrastructure plus a $10,000 incentive for each qualifying home, according to SEED's Creekside project page. The 2022 announcement set that $10,000 at one payment per house for builders who build homes larger than 1,200 square feet.
The second was the developers. KTAB reported in 2022 that the Betenboughs met SEED board members and staff at Buck's restaurant to talk through the project. They decided to develop lots off Hoyt Street rather than build the houses themselves, so individual builders could buy lots and build to what each buyer wants. Holly Betenbough described the reason in that report: "Our hearts just broke for the people, the families, that were going to drive 45 miles to commute and not live in a community." Georgia-Pacific was building a new gypsum wallboard plant in Sweetwater at the time, with 130 to 140 new jobs.
The third was an employer. In July 2024, SEED announced that Buzzi Unicem, the cement plant, was putting about $3 million into ten homes on Creekside's first cul-de-sac, with Fortezza Homes as builder. KTAB reported that those ten houses have insulated concrete foundations and solar panels with battery storage. Buzzi workers live in them temporarily as a retention benefit, then may buy a house of their own in Sweetwater. As of July 20, 2024, five of the ten had sold and five were under construction. City Manager David Vela called Creekside the city's first housing development of its size in more than 40 years.
Because of those subsidies, Creekside homes exist at all. The subsidies don't make them cheap. A new house there still lists at $175 to $177 a square foot. That makes the $100,000 appraisal average the wrong yardstick for someone choosing a home in Sweetwater. The useful comparison is an older house plus what it costs to bring it up to the standard of a new one.
The 2022 KTAB report gave a useful baseline. Adames said Sweetwater homes ran $200,000 to $240,000, and many needed $60,000 to $80,000 in renovations because of their age. Those are 2022 figures, and prices have moved since. Even so, $260,000 to $320,000 for a renovated older home is more than every Creekside plan on Fortezza's page except the 1,850-square-foot Dinah, which lists just above that range at $325,990.
The WCTCOG housing study, published in July 2025, heard the same thing from Sweetwater interviewees. Many existing homes lack upgrades or are in poor condition and need substantial remodeling, and inflation since 2020 has put some of them out of reach for moderate-income buyers. The same interviews described two newer subdivisions in the area. One targets buyers at $200,000 to $300,000 and the other targets $350,000 and up. One respondent said new construction typically sold within 30 to 60 days of being built over the 18 months before the study.
Abilene is the other comparison most buyers make. Texas A&M's Texas Real Estate Research Center put the Abilene metro median sale price at $304,900 for August 2026, across 212 closed sales. Every three-bedroom plan in Creekside lists below that median, though not by the margin the appraisal figures might suggest. Most of the price difference between the towns is in the older stock. We compared how far a budget goes in Sweetwater versus Abilene earlier this year.
On the 2017 study's one-house-a-year baseline, Creekside's progress is fast. SEED's February 9, 2026 board packet counted 24 certificates of occupancy issued in Creekside, and Creekside Apartments, the renovated Apple Creek complex, was at 82 of 120 units complete. By SEED's June 8, 2026 meeting, every apartment unit was leased and that incentive was finished. KTXS reported in June 2025 that the district had invested in more than 120 residential lots and more than 230 apartment units, and had committed more than $2 million to housing. In that report, SEED's Ethan Whittenburg said "Sweetwater just wasn't building any new homes."
With 24 certificates of occupancy issued as of February, most of Creekside's 91 lots are still open. Fortezza's site describes the subdivision as 91 lots with a covered recreation area, a main entrance off Hoyt and a second entrance at Grand Avenue. Its model home is at 1700 Cherry Street.
More projects are in SEED's pipeline. In September and October 2026, the board heard a presentation from Trafalgar Homes of Texas on a multifamily project and approved an incentive agreement for it. Almond Branch Homes was on SEED's agenda through 2026, with updates on construction start and progress at the August meeting. The Sweetwater Reporter has covered Sweetwater Station, a 55-and-over apartment community on Broadway next to Creative Graphics Solutions.
The larger question is a few years away. In a September 2026 release, IREN said construction of 300 megawatts of data center capacity at its Sweetwater 1 site was continuing, with delivery targeted for the fourth quarter of 2027. KTAB reported no official job projections for the project. We covered what a similar buildout has done to housing in Abilene's data center housing squeeze.
The same economics apply after you buy. Most of Sweetwater's homes are old and appraised far below new construction. When the owner of a Creekside home sells, the closest comparable sales will be other Creekside homes and whatever new homes are listed in town at the time. The rest of the town's housing won't be the comparison. As long as Fortezza and any other Creekside builders keep listing new homes at $175 to $177 a square foot, those listings work as a price floor for the subdivision. A Creekside resale is competing with brand-new houses a few doors away.
Prices in the county have been rising. The FHFA all-transactions house price index for Nolan County rose about 8.5 percent from 2024 to 2025, to 305.81. The index is published as developmental, so it may be revised. For an older home, the important number is still the renovation estimate. Get it before you write an offer, and add it to the asking price before you set the house beside a new build on Creekside Avenue. Our guide to pricing a Sweetwater home goes through the same comparison from the seller's side.
If you're weighing a new build on Creekside Avenue against an older house elsewhere in Sweetwater, Tiny or Grand Realty Group can go through the asking prices and the renovation math with you before you make an offer. If you already own in Sweetwater and want to know where your house sits in that gap, get your instant home valuation and we'll go through it with you.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Explore our website to discover the latest property listings, insightful market reports, and valuable resources to empower your real estate decisions. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, seasoned investor, or looking to sell your property, Tiny or Grand Realty Group is here to make your real estate journey a seamless and rewarding experience. Thank you for considering Tiny or Grand Realty Group as your trusted real estate partner. Let’s turn your dreams into addresses!